Find the perfect match for your iPad
Choosing the right Apple Pencil for your iPad isn’t a simple task anymore. Apple dropped the Apple Pencil (USB-C) into the mix, adding to the confusion. Now, with three Pencil options, each with its own price tag, the decision-making process can be a head-scratcher.
Don’t worry, we’re here to unravel the distinctions between them and make your choice simpler. Let’s dive into the realm of Apple Pencils and find the perfect match for your iPad.
Table of Contents
The Latest Apple Pencil: Apple Pencil USB-C
The Apple Pencil is a unique Apple product that maintains its design for several releases. Introduced in 2015, the first generation was followed by the second in 2018. Breaking the expectation of a new iPad, Apple unveiled a new addition to its lineup in October 2023 – the Apple Pencil USB-C.
Now there are three Apple Pencils. The $89 Apple Pencil (1st Generation), the $119 Apple Pencil (2nd Generation) and the $69 Apple Pencil (USB-C) which arrived in November 2023. All three are available for sale and have different features and functionality.
Nearly five years after the latest release, we now have an entry-level stylus for iPads: Apple Pencil USB-C. This isn’t a replacement for the existing models. Instead, it stands as an alternative that coexists with them.
Let’s compare the three models and see which model wins across different criteria: style, compatibility, functionality, and charging.
Apple Pencils: Dimensions and Style
When you glance at the new Apple Pencil (USB-C), the first noticeable difference is its compact and slender design compared to the older models. The original Apple Pencil (1st generation) from 2015 measured 6.92 inches in length and 0.35 inches in diameter, closely resembling the size and shape of a traditional pencil. Its glossy plastic material, while somewhat slippery, makes it prone to rolling off surfaces.
The second-generation Apple Pencil (2018) is a little shorter at 6.53 inches but retains the 0.35-inch diameter. It maintains the same thickness and weight (0.73 ounces). Designed with a flat side for improved usability, it features a matte plastic build that offers a comfortable and balanced feel. Apple Pencil Gen 2 definitely wins over Gen 1 in terms of style and ergonomic features.
In contrast, the latest Apple Pencil USB-C stands as the most compact, measuring 6.1 inches in length and featuring a smaller diameter of 0.29 inches. It’s the shortest and lightest among the trio. Sporting a matte finish and a flat side akin to the 2nd Gen Pencil, it provides a comfortable grip.
All three models share a common trait – a replaceable tip that is compatible with third-party alternatives.
iPad Compatibility
Before you decide on which Apple Pencil to get, make sure it’s compatible with your iPad. Don’t forget that iPads released before 2015 are not compatible with any version of the Apple Pencil. So, before diving into your creative endeavors, double-check that your future Apple Pencil aligns with the specific iPad you own.
Here’s the breakdown of the compatibility of each Apple Pencil with various iPad models.
Apple Pencil (Generation 1):
- iPad Pro 12.9-inch 1st and 2nd generation
- iPad Pro 10.5-inch
- iPad Pro 9.7-inch
- iPad Air 3rd generation
- iPad mini 5th generation
- iPad 6th, 7th, 8th, 9th, and 10th generation
Apple Pencil (Generation 2):
- iPad Pro 12.9-inch 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation
- iPad Pro 11-inch 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th generation
- iPad Air 4th and 5th generation
- iPad mini 6th generation
Apple Pencil (USB-C):
- iPad Pro 12.9-inch 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th generation
- iPad Pro 11-inch 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th generation
- iPad Air 4th and 5th generation
- iPad mini 6th generation
- iPad 10th generation
Apple Pencil 1st Gen is compatible with most iPads. However, Apple Pencil 2nd Gen is compatible with most Pro and Air models (but not with the regular iPad models). Finally, the USB-C version is compatible with all newer iPads. So if you’re looking for the most versatile model that’s compatible with the most iPad models, Apple Pencil Gen 1 is still the one you should get.
Performance & Stylus Features
Apple Pencils, across their various generations, come with a set of features designed to cater to different creative needs. Here’s a breakdown to help you pick the one that suits your preferences and your needs.
All three versions – the 1st and 2nd Generation Apple Pencils and the USB-C Pencil – share similar features, including pixel-level precision, low latency, and tilt sensitivity. They collectively ensure exceptional accuracy in writing and sketching, a responsive and immediate feel to your inputs, and the ability to incorporate shading and nuanced effects by adjusting the Pencil’s angle.
Both the 1st and 2nd Generation Pencils take it a step further by supporting pressure sensitivity. With the capability to measure 4,096 levels of pressure, artists can enjoy a more natural writing and drawing experience. However, this is where the 1st Generation Pencil’s feature set ends.
The 2nd Gen Pencil stands out as the most feature-rich among the trio. It has a magnetic attachment, wireless pairing and charging, hover functionality on the iPad Pro, a double-tap feature for changing writing tools, and the option for free engraving when purchased directly from Apple. The Hover tool seems handy, as it offers a preview of where the Pencil will mark the screen before touching the tip to the glass. The ability to quickly switch between pencil, eraser, highlighter, or marker also adds a layer of convenience.
On the other hand, the USB-C Pencil supports Hover but omits a few advanced features present in the 2nd Gen model, such as pressure sensitivity, magnetic pairing and charging, double-tap functionality, and free engraving. But if those are the features you don’t need, you can enjoy a substantial discount as the USB-C version is a lot cheaper compared to the 2nd Gen.
The USB-C Pencil is a more budget-friendly stylus that doesn’t compromise essential functionalities. For example, it still has magnetic attachment capabilities, similar to the second-gen model, allowing it to stick magnetically to an iPad.
All three Apple Pencils seamlessly integrate with creativity apps like Evernote, GarageBand, Illustrator, iMovie, Photoshop, and Procreate. They’re also compatible with nearly all iPad apps for basic input and functionality.
Pairing and Charging
All Apple Pencil models connect to your iPad using Bluetooth, making sure you have a seamless creative experience. However, the process of pairing and charging differs across the generations.
Pairing
The original Apple Pencil (Gen 1) employs a Lightning connector hidden under a removable cap. To pair and charge, you’d plug it into the iPad’s Lightning port – a somewhat awkward process.
The second-gen Apple Pencil eliminates the physical connection, and opts for wireless charging and magnetic attachment. A simple snap onto the iPad’s side initiates both pairing and charging. This is undoubtedly a more elegant and convenient solution.
The new Apple Pencil USB-C brings back a physical connection but introduces a built-in USB-C port. This innovative design, under a slide-up cap, allows you to pair and charge your Apple Pencil using a USB-C to USB-C cable. Additionally, like its predecessor, it can wirelessly charge when you attach it magnetically to the iPad.
Charging
The 1st Gen Apple Pencil relies on a Lightning connector, either plugging directly into a Lightning-equipped iPad or using an included adapter for charging via a Lightning cable.
The 2nd Gen Pencil enhances the charging experience with magnetic attachment, sticking to the flat edge of compatible iPads. This method not only makes charging simple but also keeps the Pencil conveniently accessible.
The Apple Pencil USB-C comes with a USB-C charging port, neatly tucked under a sliding end cap. With this design, you don’t need a separate adapter. It ensures a secure connection. Initial pairing involves connecting the USB-C to USB-C cable to your iPad, but after that charging can be done with any power brick.
Depending on which method of charging you prefer, it may affect your choice of the Apple Pencil model.
Pricing & Where to Buy
The Apple Pencil USB-C, priced at $69, stands out as a more economical choice compared to its counterparts – the $119 second-generation Apple Pencil and the $89 first-gen version. However, this affordability comes with a trade-off in terms of features.
While the $50 savings may appeal to budget-conscious users, don’t forget about the compromises. For example, you’ll be trading off pressure sensitivity. This feature, present in the pricier models, adds a layer of complexity and richness to the creative experience. Something you might find important as an artist.
Another trade-off is the loss of the Double-Tap function, which can potentially affect productivity. The exclusion of wireless charging and pairing capabilities may also impact your convenience.
You can purchase all of these models from the official Apple Store. Alternatively, they’re available on Amazon, often on sale. If you’re lucky, you can get the more advanced Gen 2 model for a price nearing that of the USB-C version.
Which Apple Pencil Is Best For You?
Ultimately, choosing the right Apple Pencil relies on your needs and the iPad model you’re using. If your iPad is compatible with more than one Apple Pencil, check out the features they offer and consider how much money you’re willing to spend on it – that should make the choice pretty clear for you.
